On Sunday, February 19, 1998, after 45
minutes of our independent room-to-room
assessments, my wife Annie and I came together in
the dining room of a Waltham, MA condominium that
had been listed for sale for the first time that day.
"You know, we could buy this," I
said.
"Do you want to?" she replied.
"It meets all of our specs," I
offered.
"The kids will think we're crazy, buying the
first place we see," said she. "But it beats going
through 52 different houses like we did twenty years
ago."
We made a fair offer, and two hours after
the open house ended, it was accepted. The kids, of
course, were surprised. They didn't know that we
were even thinking about moving. But after some
discussion, they all agreed we weren't crazy. Four
months later, the big house in Lexington that the
five of
them had grown up and out of was just great
memories, at least as far as the Howe Family
was
concerned.
What our children also did not know was
that Annie and I had spent most of our Valentine's
Day
dinner five days earlier drawing up specifications
along the lines of "If we were ever going to move,
what
would we be looking for?" This came three days after
close neighborhood friends had introduced the condo
concept to us by announcing that they were
downsizing, "in advance of the baby boomers," who
likely would be bidding up condo prices very soon.
Nine years have passed and we haven't
second-guessed ourselves once. We knew what
we
wanted and what it was worth to us. Twenty-plus
years of marriage will do that for you.
Last month I was reminded of this
serendipitous decision when the owner of a client
company announced to the management team that he
had purchased an $80,000 piece of equipment
without consulting all of us. For a long time, he
said,
he'd been looking for a good deal on this unit, and the
manufacturer's rep made the right proposal. No ROI
analysis. No negotiation of price or terms. No
plugging into the cash flow forecast to see how we'd
pay for it. It was just "right," based on his thirty
years in
the business.
I hope that he is right, and that it's
not the
exception that proves the rule. Because Rule #1
in
purchasing (now known as procurement)
management is never go to market without a
shopping list. In the case of capital equipment,
the list
should include the following:
- Minimum and maximum operating
specifications;
- Price range vs. capacity;
- Special features;
- Time to deliver;
- Terms;
- Service availability and price;
- Analysis of other options;
- Reputation of vendor(s); and
- References on specific piece of
equipment.
Rule #2, which in this case was honored, is
never
accept the first price offered
unless you know that there are availability issues.
Very seldom is there just one source for a product
or
service: it's the job of Procurement to generate
multiple quotes and to push back on prices. [See
sidebar.]
Rule #3 recognizes that effective
buying
involves selling: before you make a significant
purchase, connect with a vendor's salesperson.
A
written RFQ or RFP without a human contact gets
unexceptional treatment. Having a
salesperson on
your side gives you an advocate for price, terms,
expedited delivery, and problem-solving.
Rule #4 requires that you always use
a
written purchase order with printed company logo to
document exactly what you have bought:
- Item number
- Description of product or service
- Quantity
- Price or fee, including tax
- Delivery charges with method of shipping
- Delivery date
- Terms
- Ship-to address
- Bill-to address
- Purchase order number and date issued
Rule #5 says that you pay for nothing without
documentation to prove that it
was received as ordered. With product
purchases,
this means verifying quantity and condition upon
delivery—matching shipping documents
against the original P.O.
For the Accounts Payable department, making certain
that nothing gets paid without checking the invoice
against the P.O. and the receiving document is
basic.
The best A/P managers, moreover, initiate the next
step themselves—calling the vendor and/or
shipper immediately to question any charges or
conditions that were not part of the deal. The longer
this remains unchallenged, the harder it is to resolve.
Rule #6 requires you to eliminate independent
purchasing activity and decision-making, even if it
means pushing back on the owner. Review expenses
vs. the budget every month to identify where your key
variances lie, and hold unauthorized spenders
accountable.
At the risk of oversimplifying,
these purchasing principles apply almost as well
personally as they do professionally. For the
Waltham
condo, we had the specs, and we paid for the value to
us. The availability of our time to shop was limited,
and the market for big homes in Lexington was
peaking (though it turned out that we were 18 months
early on that). The Purchase and Sale Agreement
was an effective P.O., and our due diligence
eliminated surprises after the deal closed.
So hopefully, reading this, our kids will
continue to agree that we weren't crazy at all, now that
they have the perspective of being in the housing
market themselves. Don't forget those spec
sheets,
you guys!